Yellow Cake with Butter Frosting – Feingold Stage 1


cup butter (1 ½ sticks)     (Land O’
Lakes or Horizon Organic)     

1 ½
cups sugar
eggs  (bring to room temp by placing in a
bowl of warm water)
4 ½
tsp baking powder
tsp salt
2/3 cups all purpose flour  (I use King Arthur
unbleached flour)
cup milk  (any whole milk)
1 ½
tsp vanilla
Preheat oven to 375
Cream butter and
sugar.  Let butter sit out for half an
hour to an hour first to soften.
Add eggs one at a
time, beating well after each.  (*Add
choc. if doing choc. cake)
Add baking powder
and salt, beat well. 
Beating just
enough to mix (do not overbeat), add part of the flour, then part of the milk,
repeating 3-4 times until all is mixed in.
Add the
Bake in greased
(I use butter) and floured pan.  Cake is
done when toothpick comes out clean. 
For 9” round layers bake for
25 minutes              For 10” tube pan bake for 40
For 9×13 pan bake for 30
minutes                        For
cupcakes bake for 18-19 minutes
*If making a chocolate cake,
add 3 TB cocoa or 1 ½ blocks of chocolate, melted. 

Butter Frosting    or                                   1.5 times recipe

6 TB butter                                                    9
TB butter (1 stick plus 1 TB)
2 cups powdered sugar                                 3 cups powdered sugar
4 TB milk, divided                                        6 TB
milk, divided  
1 ½ tsp. Vanilla                                             2  1/4  tsp. vanilla
In a large mixing bowl cream
butter till light and fluffy.  Gradually
add half the powdered sugar, beating well. 
Beat in 2 TB milk and the vanilla. 
Gradually add the remaining powdered sugar, beating constantly.  Beat in enough milk to make frosting of
spreading consistency.  If adding liquid
for color, such as juice from frozen strawberries or raspberries, sub the juice
for the milk until you reach the desired color. 

Note:  You can buy a bunny shaped cake pan and
plastic googly eyes at Wal-Mart. (craft section).  Grease generously with oil and flour.

The frosting is a little thin because of all the butter so it’s easiest to make the cake in a pan instead of a layer cake, but a layer cake is still doable. Or you could use chocolate frosting instead. 

Chocolate Frosting

Here’s a bunny cake I made for my son’s 2nd birthday.

Feingold Stage 1

Written by Sheri Fortes - Visit Website

Author of "All Natural Mom's Guide to the Feingold Diet"

Follow me on Facebook, Pinterest, and Instagram

The Treating ADHD Naturally Conference is coming back to Chicago May 23, 2018! More details coming soon at

Posted in Recipes and tagged .

One Comment

  1. Pingback: Chocolate Frosting – Feingold Stage 1 – All Natural Mom

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *